Current:Home > Contact-usJ&J tried to block lawsuits from 40,000 cancer patients. A court wants answers-LoTradeCoin
J&J tried to block lawsuits from 40,000 cancer patients. A court wants answers
View Date:2025-01-14 11:55:01
An attorney for Johnson and Johnson faced probing questions Monday over the corporation's use of a controversial bankruptcy maneuver that has frozen tens of thousands of lawsuits linked to Johnson's baby powder.
During the hearing, members of a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit in Philadelphia asked whether J&J had used the legal strategy to gain "a litigation advantage" over roughly 40,000 cancer patients who have sued the company.
The cases were filed mostly by women. They claim Johnson's iconic talc baby powder was contaminated with asbestos, which caused their mesothelioma or ovarian cancers.
J&J, which announced last month it would suspend all talc baby powder sales worldwide, has denied any wrongdoing.
Attorney Neal Katyal, representing the company, responded by arguing that the bankruptcy maneuver — known as the "Texas two-step" — would benefit victims by producing a faster settlement, possibly worth as much as $61 billion.
Katyal acknowledged criticism that a "big company that has all these profits is somehow trying to evade liability."
But he said that if the tsunami of baby powder-related cases were allowed to play out in civil courts it would create legal chaos and "reduce the number of dollars available to claimants."
The "Texas two-step" and how it worked for J& J
Here's how the legal maneuver known as the "Texas two-step" worked in this case.
In October of last year, J&J — which is headquartered in New Jersey — used a wrinkle in Texas state law to spin off a new subsidiary called LTL.
The healthcare giant pushed all baby powder-related liabilities onto the new firm's books.
Within a matter of days, LTL relocated from Texas to North Carolina and filed for bankruptcy, effectively halting the baby powder lawsuits.
The U.S. Appeals for the Third Circuit will eventually rule on whether LTL's bankruptcy was filed in good faith and whether it should shield J and J from baby powder related lawsuits.
During Monday's session, attorneys representing women with claims against J&J slammed the healthcare giant's legal strategy.
"Talc victims ... are mired in bankruptcy as they die," said attorney Jeffrey Lamken.
He noted that during the LTL bankruptcy process, Johnson and Johnson has paid out billions of dollars to shareholders and for stock buy-backs - a practice not allowed for firms that are actually bankrupt.
Meanwhile, women who filed cancer lawsuits against the corporation have been forced to wait and "can only get more desperate as they face medical expenses and come closer to their own deaths," Lamken argued.
Attorneys representing cancer patients say the civil court system, not the bankruptcy court, is the proper venue for establishing the corporation's liability.
This case that could reshape civil justice in the U.S
The U.S. Department of Justice has also challenged J&J's bankruptcy maneuver.
On Monday, a DOJ attorney argued that if this legal strategy is upheld by the courts, it would open the door to other non-bankrupt companies and wealthy individuals using similar maneuvers to avoid liability.
"If Johnson and Johnson can get away with this bankruptcy, what's to stop any other company in America from doing the same thing?" asked Sean Janda, an attorney representing the U.S. Trustee, a division of DOJ that oversees bankruptcy cases.
J&J's strategy has also sparked criticism from some members of Congress as well as public outrage.
Speaking late last year, Hanna Wilt who was sick with mesothelioma voiced fury over the delay in her baby powder lawsuit against the company.
"What I see is who can play the game best," Wilt told NPR. "Big corporations trying to work the system in a way they don't have to take full responsibility is not something new."
Wilt died in February of this year at age 27.
It's unclear how quickly the Third Circuit will rule, though judges tend to move quickly in bankruptcy-related cases. Legal experts have suggested that regardless of the outcome, an appeal will likely be filed to the US Supreme Court.
veryGood! (3418)
Related
- Zendaya Shares When She Feels Extra Safe With Boyfriend Tom Holland
- Gary Wright, 'Dream Weaver' and 'Love is Alive' singer, dies at 80 after health battle: Reports
- Kansas newspaper’s lawyer says police didn’t follow warrant in last month’s newsroom search
- What makes a good TV guest star?
- Massive dust storm reduces visibility, causes vehicle pileup on central California highway
- Colorado, Duke surge into the AP Top 25 after huge upsets; Florida State climbs into top five
- While North Carolina gambling opponents rally, Republicans weigh whether to embrace more casinos
- Wait times to exit Burning Man drop after flooding left tens of thousands stranded in Nevada desert
- Alexandra Daddario Shares Candid Photo of Her Postpartum Body 6 Days After Giving Birth
- World War I memorials in France and Belgium are vying again to become UNESCO World Heritage sites
Ranking
- Mike Tyson concedes the role of villain to young foe in 58-year-old’s fight with Jake Paul
- Wet roads and speed factored into car crashing into Denny’s restaurant, Texas police chief says
- Retired Mississippi trooper killed after car rolls on top of him at the scene of a crash
- Alaska couple reunited with cat 26 days after home collapsed into river swollen by glacial outburst
- Full House Star Dave Coulier Shares Stage 3 Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma Diagnosis
- Dozens injured after Eritrean government supporters, opponents clash at protest in Israel
- Airbnb limits some new reservations in New York City as short-term rental regulations go into effect
- Utah special election primary offers glimpse into Republican voters’ thoughts on Trump indictments
Recommendation
-
Brian Austin Green Shares Message to Sharna Burgess Amid Ex Megan Fox's Baby News
-
Summer House's Danielle Olivera Subtly Weighs in on Carl Radke & Lindsay Hubbard's Breakup
-
See Michael Jackson’s Sons Blanket and Prince in New Jackson Family Photo
-
NFL head coach hot seat rankings: Ron Rivera, Mike McCarthy on notice entering 2023
-
Martha Stewart playfully pushes Drew Barrymore away in touchy interview
-
61 indicted in Georgia on racketeering charges connected to ‘Stop Cop City’ movement
-
Delaware man who police blocked from warning drivers of speed trap wins $50,000 judgment
-
At least 14 dead in boating, swimming incidents over Labor Day weekend across the US